Start here: the AutoShop Answers & Auto Hospitality story
Learn/Operating model
Operating model11 min read

Shopmonkey vs Mitchell 1: Cloud Platform or Desktop Software for Your Second Location

Shopmonkey is cloud-based with most features included. Mitchell 1 runs on desktop and charges separately for texting, digital inspections, and payment processing. Both take six months to implement and show ROI at six months.

By AutoShop Answers
Empty auto repair shop scene, empty, clean service bay with a vehicle raised on a two-post lift, tool cart in the foreground

Shopmonkey vs Mitchell 1: Cloud Platform or Desktop Software for Your Second Location

You run two or three locations. The newer store is bleeding. You need visibility into repair orders, parts usage, and technician capacity at both sites without driving between them.

The shopmonkey vs mitchell 1 decision comes down to access and add-on costs.

Shopmonkey is cloud-based. You open it from any device, anywhere. Mitchell 1 is desktop-installed software that runs on a workstation at each location.

Mitchell 1 charges separately for two-way texting, digital inspections, integrated payments, QuickBooks sync, appointment reminders, and online review management. Shopmonkey includes most of those features in its base and mid-tier plans.

Both systems take six months to implement and six months to return on investment, based on 100 responses each.

Cloud or Desktop

Shopmonkey is cloud-based. You log in from a tablet at the counter, your laptop at home, or your phone in the parts aisle.

Mitchell 1 is desktop-installed software. Each location runs its own instance. Remote access requires terminal services or a VPN.

If your service advisor at the second location texts you a question about a repair order, you can open Shopmonkey from your phone and see the estimate, the parts ordered, and the customer messages. With Mitchell 1, you drive to that shop or remote into the desktop.

Neither approach is wrong. Some operators prefer a local install and control over backups. Others need real-time access from multiple devices.

What Each Platform Includes

Shopmonkey pricing is flat monthly per location. Mitchell 1 pricing is not publicly listed, so request a written quote that itemizes software, add-ons, and annual data subscriptions.

Features Included in Shopmonkey Plans

FeatureShopmonkeyMitchell 1
Cloud-based accessIncludedNo, desktop-installed
Two-way textingIncluded in all plansMessageCenter add-on
Digital vehicle inspectionsClever plan and aboveOneFlow Inspections add-on
Mobile app for techniciansiOS and AndroidInspections app on iOS and Android
Integrated paymentsIncluded, with ACH and BNPLIntegrated Payment Processing add-on
QuickBooks Online syncBuilt-in, Clever and aboveAccounting Link add-on
Appointment remindersIncluded in all plansProPack Toolbox add-on
Online reviews managementCRM Essentials add-onSocialCRM add-on
Multi-language supportEnglish, French, SpanishEnglish

Shopmonkey Basic is $239.00 per month and includes three users, two-way texting, and integrated payments. Clever is $399.00 per month and adds digital inspections and QuickBooks sync. Genius is $499.00 per month. Each additional user costs $20 per month.

Annual-savings rates drop those figures to $215, $359, and $449 per month.

Mitchell 1 does not publish monthly pricing. Desktop shops typically pay an upfront license fee plus annual data updates. Add-ons are quoted separately.

User Limits and Team Access

Shopmonkey Basic includes three users, Clever includes four, and Genius includes five. Each extra user is $20 per month.

Tekmetric includes unlimited users with every plan at $199, $349, and $439 per month. That comparison matters if your second location has two service advisors, a shop foreman, and an owner who all need their own login.

Example: a shop with six users on Shopmonkey Clever pays $399 for the base plan plus $40 for two additional users, totaling $439 per month. The same shop on Tekmetric Grow pays $349 per month for unlimited users.

Mitchell 1 user licensing varies by edition and add-ons. Ask the vendor how many concurrent logins the base license includes and what each additional seat costs.

Add-On Costs and Feature Stacking

Mitchell 1 sells features as separate modules. Two-way texting requires MessageCenter. Digital inspections require OneFlow. Integrated payments require a payment-processing add-on. QuickBooks sync requires Accounting Link. Appointment reminders require ProPack Toolbox.

If your service advisor sends appointment reminders by text, the technician uses a tablet for inspections, and you sync invoices to QuickBooks, you pay for MessageCenter, OneFlow, Accounting Link, and ProPack Toolbox on top of the base Manager SE license.

Shopmonkey bundles most of those features. Basic includes texting, reminders, and payments. Clever adds digital inspections and QuickBooks sync.

Neither approach is cheaper in every case. A single-location shop that does not need inspections or QuickBooks might spend less on Mitchell 1 with no add-ons. A two-location shop that needs every feature will likely spend less on Shopmonkey Clever.

Request a written quote from each vendor. List every feature you use in a normal week: estimates, parts orders, inspections, customer texts, invoice sync, and payment processing. Ask for the total monthly or annual cost to run all of those at both locations.

Parts Tracking and Vendor Integration

Both systems handle parts ordering and job costing.

Shopmonkey is usage-centric by default. When you order parts through its integrated vendor tools, those orders tie to repair orders. Parts that are not tied to an RO yet may require manual entry to track accurately. Create strict policies so every part is tied to a job or added to inventory.

Mitchell 1 tracks parts purchased and parts usage separately. You can run a report comparing parts received to parts billed on repair orders. Discrepancies show up as unbilled parts or missing entries.

Parts purchased versus parts usage matters when your second location is losing money. If you purchase more than you use, cash is tied up in unbilled inventory. If you use more than you purchased, you are dipping into stock and may not be ordering enough.

Example: a shop purchases $12,000 in parts in March and bills $10,500 in parts on repair orders that month. The $1,500 gap is either inventory growth, unbilled parts, theft, or vendor overcharges. Run the parts-usage report monthly.

Payment Processing and Text-to-Pay

Integrated payments tie card transactions to repair orders, digital inspections, and text-to-pay.

Shopmonkey includes integrated payments in all plans with multiple payment types, surcharging, ACH, buy-now-pay-later, and online payments. Mitchell 1 integrated payments are available as an add-on.

Payment processing rates often cost more than the software subscription on high-volume repair orders. Before you sign, get written pricing for card-present, text-to-pay, and ACH transactions, plus payout timing, chargeback fees, and exit terms. Ask every vendor whether you can connect your own processor and whether choosing one changes your software price.

Card fees scale with volume. Small rate differences add up quickly on $1,200 brake jobs and $2,800 transmission repairs.

G2 Ratings and Implementation Time

Shopmonkey receives an 8.6 out of 10 Meets Requirements rating based on 358 responses. Mitchell 1 Automotive Repair receives an 8.2 out of 10 based on 15 responses.

Shopmonkey Ease of Use is 8.9 out of 10 based on 363 responses. Mitchell 1 Ease of Use is 8.2 out of 10 based on 16 responses.

Both systems take six months to implement based on 100 responses each. Both show return on investment at six months.

Shopmonkey Ease of Setup is 8.9 out of 10 based on 273 responses. Mitchell 1 Ease of Setup is 9.0 out of 10 based on 7 responses.

Shopmonkey Ease of Admin is 9.0 out of 10 based on 251 responses. Mitchell 1 Ease of Admin is 9.4 out of 10 based on 6 responses.

Additional comparison context is available from G2.

Mitchell 1 has fewer total reviews but scores slightly higher on setup and admin ease in the smaller sample.

Record Retention and Tax Compliance

Shop management software must keep tax records for the required time. In general, six years in Canada and three years in the U.S. Confirm the rules for your business with the CRA or the IRS.

Ask each vendor how far back the system stores repair orders, invoices, and payment records. Cloud systems typically store records indefinitely as long as the subscription is active. Desktop systems depend on local backup procedures.

If you switch systems, export all historical data before the cutover. Some vendors charge for data migration or format conversion.

Testing With Real Repair Orders

Use the free trial to run real jobs from estimate to invoice. Assign a technician and a service advisor. Note each step that takes longer than your current system.

Test these workflows:

  • Create an estimate for a customer with a 2018 Ford F-150, parts lookup included.
  • Convert the estimate to a repair order and assign it to a technician.
  • Complete a digital inspection with photos and send it to the customer by text.
  • Order parts from your vendor and tie them to the repair order.
  • Close the repair order, process a card payment, and sync the invoice to QuickBooks.

If any step fails or requires a workaround, ask the vendor how that task is handled in production. If the answer is an add-on or a manual export, factor that cost and time into your decision.

Switching From Tekmetric or Another System

Many multi-location shops already run Tekmetric at the first store. The second location may need a system that shares customer records and reporting across sites.

Tekmetric, Shopmonkey, and Mitchell 1 are all built to replace legacy desktop systems like NAPA TRACS for shops that want faster updates and easier counter access.

Tekmetric includes unlimited users at $199, $349, and $439 per month. Shopmonkey is $239, $399, and $499 per month with limited users. Mitchell 1 pricing is quoted per shop.

If you already use Tekmetric at your first location, compare the cost of adding a second Tekmetric subscription to the cost of running two different systems. Customer records, parts pricing, and labor rates do not sync between platforms.

Questions to Ask Each Vendor

Send every vendor the same list in writing:

  1. What is the total monthly cost to run this system at two locations with six users, including all features we listed?
  2. Which features require add-ons, and what does each add-on cost per month or per year?
  3. Can we access the system from mobile devices, tablets, and multiple workstations?
  4. How long does implementation take, and what does training include?
  5. Can we connect our own payment processor, or are we required to use yours?
  6. What is the payment processing rate for card-present, text-to-pay, and ACH transactions?
  7. How far back does the system store repair orders and invoices?
  8. What does data migration cost if we switch from our current system?
  9. What are the exit terms, notice period, and data-export format if we cancel?

More software selection guidance covers workflow fit, integrations, and full setup cost.

Desktop Install or Cloud Access

Mitchell 1 runs on a workstation at each location. Shopmonkey runs in a browser on any device.

If your service advisor at the second shop calls with a parts question, you open Shopmonkey from your phone. With Mitchell 1, you drive to that shop or remote into the desktop.

If your internet connection drops, Shopmonkey stops working until it reconnects. Mitchell 1 keeps running because it is installed locally.

Neither is better in every case. Cloud access matters most when you manage multiple locations and need real-time visibility. Desktop install matters most when uptime and local control are priorities.

Test both during the trial. Simulate a full day at the counter, a technician inspection in the bay, and a manager reviewing numbers from home.

Making the Call

Shopmonkey is cloud-based with most features included. Mitchell 1 is desktop software with add-ons priced separately.

Request written quotes from both. List every feature your team uses. Add up the monthly cost for two locations with six users.

Run real repair orders during the trial. If a step takes longer or requires a workaround, ask the vendor how production shops handle it.

Compare the total software cost to the payment processing cost. On high-volume tickets, the processing rate often matters more than the subscription.

Implementation and ROI both take six months for Shopmonkey and Mitchell 1 based on 100 responses each. Plan for training, data migration, and parallel operation before the cutover.

If you need help mapping software costs to shop-floor workflow, reach out with your questions.

See the model live
Practice this at the workshop.

Watch owners use this operating vocabulary in a live workshop, working on the same problems you are.

Next
Nov 21–22